
Making our voices heard
Why student journals are crucial
studentBMJ mission statement:
"To publish educational and entertaining material for medical students everywhere and facilitate international student debate on medical education, health and health policy."
Every community needs a forum to debate its ideas. The studentBMJ has provided this for medical students in the UK for the past eight years. Our aim, however, has always been to represent medical students everywhere.
Studentbmj.com, our free web based journal, has certainly helped us achieve this.
At conception, the studentBMJ was really a monthly archive of the most student relevant parts of the BMJ. It is completely owned by the BMJ publishing group and is produced out of its offices in London, England. Two years after its launch, it was decided to take on a student editor each year. This editor took a year out of medical school to take control of commissioning, editing and writing, and began to change the nature of the journal. It started to use more original material and was redesigned to appeal to its student readership. Since then this appeal has continued to grow. It consists of editorials, news, education, papers and review sections. Most is specially commissioned, and written by doctors in tune with the educational and extracurricular needs and interests of students. The student editor post is now advertised every year and a successor selected after interview, by editors at the BMJ.
Students write the majority of our Life section. Any student can send in articles at any time. Many have not written before, and do not have to do anything more than send an article via email. They cover the diverse range of thoughts, aspirations, and accomplishments that medical students experience all over the world. Medical students studying anywhere in the world are eligible to write for our journal. We also pay up to £100 for articles accepted. If you have an original idea, whether you have written for a journal before or not, we would be interested in hearing from you. You can contact us at the email address at the end of this article. We also provide clear information on the sort of material we are looking for on our website at
www.studentbmj.com/writing. Why, however, should we plug resources into a journal specifically for medical students?
Addressing the problems
The issues that we need to discuss deserve dedicated journal space. Stress in medical students is a common phenomenon, for
instance.1 The studentBMJ was able to highlight this issue, and point out ways that students can deal with stress more effectively. We recently addressed eating disorders in students and
doctors.2 Simple advice and knowing about the resources available can be of great help to those who may be suffering in silence. Cheating at medical school generated hundreds of responses from many health
professionals,4 and unethical conduct is an area that we have rightly devoted our attention to several
times.5 Being able to comment on issues such as admissions policies, and teaching
styles3 may affect many future generations of doctors as well.
Catering for our needs
The nature of medical journal development is traditionally slow. Student journals can generally adapt to reader's demands much more rapidly. This means the content can closely reflect what you want to read. Design and layout is often more appealing and accessible as well. An example of this is the 'Papers' section of the
studentBMJ. This has traditionally been perceived as irrelevant and uninteresting. While we have not abolished this section, we have been able to use shorter formats, add in commentaries and use more interesting presentation to make it more appealing.
Students do much more than study at medical school. We are people too! We write, paint, campaign, travel, and vote as well. This is why our journals have to be flexible and varied in a way that is difficult for mainstream medical journals to do. We also appreciate educational material presented in innovative formats to aid our learning. We can provide case based learning with an emphasis on practical tips and aide memoirs.
Success depends on you
Remember the studentBMJ is your journal. It is the readers and student contributors who make the journal great. With your help, it can go from strength to strength.
Jason O' Neale Roach editor, studentBMJ
(studenteditor@bmj.com)
1. Roach JO, Guthrie E. Dealing with stress.
StudentBMJ 2000;8:218-219
2. Armstrong R. Why I left medicine. StudentBMJ 2000;8:205
3. Wykurz G. Can patients teach students. StudentBMJ 2000;8:260-261
4. Smith R. Cheating at medical school. BMJ 2000;321:398
5. Yamey G, Roach JO. Witnessing unethical conduct: the effects. StudentBMJ 2001;9:2-3
|